ObjectiveTo systematically review the willingness rate of the first consultation in primary health care institutions among Chinese residents.MethodsCNKI, WanFang Data, VIP, PubMed, Web of Science and EMbase databases were electronically searched to collect cross-sectional studies on the willingness rate of the first consultation in primary health care institutions of residents in China from January 2006 to November 2020. Two reviewers independently screened literature, extracted data and assessed the risk of bias of included studies; meta-analysis was then performed using Stata 14.1 software.ResultsA total of 26 cross-sectional studies involving 36 430 subjects were included. The results of meta-analysis showed that the willingness rate of Chinese residents for the first consultation in primary health care institutions was 61.4% (95%CI 54.5% to 68.3%). The results of subgroup analysis showed that for the willingness rates of the first treatment at the grassroots level in male and female residents were 65.6% and 64.9%; urban and rural residents were 49.9% and 58.9%; <60 and ≥60 years old residents were 60.5% and 71.6%; primary school and below, junior high school, high school or technical secondary school, junior college or above educational level residents were 72.8%, 68.1%, 64.2%, and 52.8%; employees, residents, and other types of insurance residents were 74.1%, 75.9%, and 64.4%; residents with monthly income <3 000, 3 000-5 000, and >5 000 yuan were 65.8%, 65.3%, and 58.5%; high, medium, and poor levels of health status residents were 56.8%, 52.6%, and 48.8%; with and without chronic diseases residents were 61.0% and 56.9%; with and without spouse residents were 63.9% and 64.6%; with and without contracted family doctor residents were 87.1% and 62.6%; on duty, retired, and other employment status residents were 70.7%, 69.9% and 71.5%; primary medical institutions residents those were satisfied, average, and dissatisfied were 77.3%, 60.7%, and 49.4%.ConclusionsCurrent evidence suggests that it remains room for improvement in the level of willingness of Chinese residents for first consultation in primary health care institutions. Residence, age, educational level, type of medical insurance, income level, health level, family doctors contracted status, and satisfaction with primary medical institutions have an impact on residents' willingness to receive first treatment at primary hospitals. Due to limited quality and quantity of the included studies, more high quality studies are needed to verify above conclusions.
ObjectiveTo evaluate the current status of primary healthcare system reform in Xinjin county, in order to provide baseline data for improving the healthcare service system and population health in Chengdu. MethodsPrimary health care services and population health in Xinjin county were quantitatively described and compared. Resultsa) Eleven township hospitals (100%) and 89 village clinics (66.42%) were upgraded according to the national standards. The management of 60 village clinics were integrated with township hospitals. And 417 and 76 essential healthcare services were provided by township hospitals and village clinics, respectively. b) In 2010, the number of outpatients and inpatients in Xinjin county were increased by 24.2% and 46.3% respectively compared to those of 2009, while the costs per outpatient visit and inpatient discharge were reduced by 21.5% and 18.6% respectively. c) In 2010, health records of 98.2% of population in Xinjin county have been established; 96.3% of pregnant women were managed systematically; 98.8% of children immunization programs were implemented; 100% patients with severe mental disorders and about 78% with hypertension and diabetes were in follow-up and treatment; and 28.8% of total population got the free physical exams in 2010. d) The essential medicine accounted for 96.7% of total types of medicines and 97.8% of total expenditure of medicines in primarily healthcare institutions in Xinjin. The cost of medicine management was reduced from 8.5% to 4.2% while the medicine turnover rate was increased by 50%. e) Average life expectancy in Xinjin county was 77.97 years, infant mortality rate was 6.82‰ in 2010; and there was no maternal death in recent 8 years. f) The regional healthcare information system was established covering three-tier rural health care network spanning the county, township and village. Conclusiona) The primary healthcare system reform in Xinjin county improves the infrastructure of primary care system, the utilization of essential medical care, essential public health service, and essential medicines. b) Life expectancy, infant mortality rate and maternal mortality of Xinjin county are better than the average levels in Sichuan province and China. Xinjin county is a representative pilot county for healthcare service system reform in Chengdu city and a nice model to successfully promote healthcare system reform based on regional healthcare information system.
Basing on the special geographical environment, population, economic level and medical conditions of the areas along the plateau railway, as well as the policy requirements of primary healthcare institutions in China, combining the reality and early practice of the areas along the plateau railway in China, the High Altitude Medicine Committee of Sichuan Medical Association gathered the experts in the field of high altitude medicine in China, and launched the Expert Consensus on Basic Requirements for Primary Healthcare Institutions in Areas Along the Plateau Railway. Its content covers the scale and layout, infrastructure, personnel allocation and service capacity, material allocation of primary healthcare institutions in areas along the plateau railway, and provides professional guidance for primary healthcare institutions in these areas.
ObjectiveTo comprehensively evaluate the essential public health service in Xinjin county of Chengdu from 2009 to April 2011, so as to provide evidence for improving primary healthcare system reform in Chengdu city. MethodsThe data was collected from the Xinjin county-wide health information system. The electronic health records, chronic disease management, childbirth management and mental health were quantitatively described and compared. Resultsa) In 2010, 88 772 residents had the physical examination and health assessment, among which, 14 497 (16%) were detected with some health problems. The average cost per positive detection was RMB 122.5 yuan. b) Up to April 2011, 98.2% of people in Xinjin county have their health records but the proportions were ranged from 68.08% to 109.02% in different primary healthcare providers. The details of the most health records were incomplete. c) 7 318 patients with hypertension and 2 187 diabetes mellitus were detected, and among them, 90.1% of patients with hypertension and 95.1% of patients with diabetes had their health records for chronic diseases management. d) The rate of stillbirth or neonatal mortality was lower than 4‰. There was no maternal death in the 8 years. But the cesarean section rate was about 61%. e) 97.3% of the patients with mental disorders were supervised in 2010, which was reduced by 2.7% compared to 2009. Conclusionsa) There is low proportion of all the residents in Xinjin having physical examination and health assessment and the rate of diseases detection is low as well. b) There is very wide coverage of health records for residents in Xinjin county, nearly universal coverage. c) The health records for the chronic disease patients were well-established, but the early detection rate of the chronic diseases is low. d) High proportion of the patients with mental disorders is supervised. e) The strategy that only county-level hospitals could provide obstetrical service instead of township hospitals is successful to reduce the neonatal mortality and maternal mortality. However, the cesarean section rate is high. f) It acts, to some extent, as a model to successfully improve the essential public health service and management based on the conuty-wide healthcare information system. However, the data quality, data mining and data utilization should be further improved
ObjectiveTo analyze the accessibility of primary care in Sichuan Province from both the perspective of doctors, patients, and field workers, and then make some policy recommendations.MethodsBased on the Quality and Costs of Primary Care in Europe primary care questionnaire, we surveyed 48 primary care facilities from six cities / states in Sichuan by multi-stage stratified random sampling method, taking in account of the regional development level from November 2017 to December 2018. Then integrated accessibility score for primary care was calculated based on the question items for both doctors and patients.ResultsThis study effectively surveyed 319 primary care doctors and 641 patients. In general, the integrated accessibility score for primary care for these areas was 0.25. The accessibility of primary care was worst in less-developed regions (0.23), while it was much better in medium-developed area (0.30) and developed area (0.28).ConclusionsWe can do lots of things to improve accessibility of primary care. Evidence based policies are needed to promote this goal that everyone will have access to basic medical and health services.
ObjectiveTo investigate the drug utilization in primary healthcare system of Xinjin county of Chengdu in 2010. MethodsThe drug utilization information in regional health information platform of Xinjin county were collected. Microsoft Excel 2003 software was used to describe the types, forms and expenditure of medicines, particularly the use of antibiotics among outpatients and inpatients. ResultsThe drug utilization of 17 hospitals in Xinjin county in 2010 was summarized below:a) there were 1 507, 1 356 and 695 kinds of drugs dispended for outpatients, and 1 271, 1 023 and 317 for inpatients in county-level hospitals (CLH), township hospitals (TH) and community healthcare centre (CHC), respectively. Among which, oral biomedicine and traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) accounted for about 45% of total types, and 46% to 73% of total drug expenditure among outpatients; while oral biomedicine and the injection accounted 37% to 61% of total types of medicines dispended to inpatients, particularly injection of biomedicine accounting for over 75% of total drug expenditure among inpatients. b) The expenditure of top 30 drugs in primary care hospitals accounted for 50% of total drug expenditure among outpatients and over 85% among inpatients. c) Among the top 20 drugs, there were 15 antibiotics, which accounted for 26.5% of total drug expenditure in Xinjin county. The top 10 antibiotics were mainly cephalosporin, accounting for 59.36% and 66.27% of total antibiotics expenditure among outpatients and inpatients respectively. Conclusiona) The main forms of medicines dispended to outpatients are oral biomedicine and TCM, while oral agents and injection of biomedicine are the majority of medicines used for inpatients. b) The top 30 drugs should be monitored for rational use of drugs considering the huge expenditure. And c) the types, proportion of use and expenses of antimicrobial drugs ranked the first in CLH, CHC and TH, which may imply irrational use of antibiotics.
Objective To investigate the medical technical services of the primary health care institutions in Chengdu and provide suggestions to improve their capability. Methods From October to November 2016, a questionnaire survey was conducted towards all the 390 primary health care institutions (including urban community health service centers and rural township health centers) in the 22 districts/cities/counties of Chengdu. Descriptive statistical methods was used for analysis. Results A total of 390 questionnaires were issued, and 379 valid questionnaires were recovered. In the primary health care institutions, the proportion of laboratory technicians, ultrasound technicians, electrocardiogram technicians and radiological technicians accounting for overall medical staffs was 3.32%, 2.04%, 1.75%, and 2.43%, respectively. The setup rate of laboratory, B-ultrasonic room, electrocardiogram room in the urban community health service centers was 94.02%, 93.16%, and 94.02%, respectively, which was similar with the rural township health centers (93.51%, 95.42%, and 90.08%, respectively). The top three medical technical services provided by the primary health care institutions were blood glucose test (96.04%), blood routine test (95.25%) and urinary routine test (95.25%), and the latter three were lung function test (18.21%), blood gas analysis (8.18%) and CT (5.28%). Conclusion Primary health care institutions in Chengdu need to improve the standardization of medical technical projcects and improve their service capability.
Objective To provide basis to improve the ability of primary care services in Chengdu by comparatively analyzing inpatient medical service of primary medical institutions (community health service centers and township health centers). Methods From October to November 2016, the data of inpatient services in primary medical institutions in Chengdu, including 390 primary medical institutions in 22 districts (cities) and counties, were investigated by questionnaire. SPSS 19.0 was used for data collection and analysis, while the univariate logistic regression and multiple logistic regression were used to analyze the influencing factors. Results It was more common for rural primary medical institutions to carry out inpatient medical services than urban (96.18% vs. 53.84%). The coverage rate of insurance in urban areas was higher than rural areas (98.41% vs. 90.87%), while the rate of adopting clinical pathway of single disease was quite low both in urban areas (23.81%) and rural areas (18.25%). Primary medical institutions in urban areas launched more special projects of inpatient services than those in rural areas (14.29%–17.46% vs. 3.57%–7.54%). The total amount of inpatient medical services in 2015 in rural areas was larger than urban areas (529 611 vs. 103 912), the total number of inpatient services in rural was 5.09 times that in urban primary medical institutions, the average inpatient services in 2015 per one rural primary medical institution was 1.27 times that in urban, per 10 000 residents in rural areas consumed 3.01 times more inpatient medical services than those in urban areas in average, the median beds utilization efficiency in rural areas was better than in urban areas (74.47% vs. 22.47%); work intensity of inpatient medical service in rural areas was greater than in urban areas (234.57 vs. 81.74 cases per year per doctor). The number of inpatient services was positively related to population in service (when less than 100 000 residents), inpatient beds, the number of drugs, the number of medical staff. Conclusions For inpatient medical service, there are obvious differences between urban and rural areas in Chengdu. Therefore, above differences should be taken into full consideration in the allocation of resources in primary medical institutions. Thus more targeted management measures should be formulated.