Objective To analyze the status of applying diagnostic test in imaging scientific study internationally and domestically, and to compare the application of the image diagnostic studies of our country with that of abroad. Method We hand-searched the diagnosis tests published in the "Chinese Journal of Radiology", the most influential in China, and in "Radiology’’, the most influential abroad, from 1998 to 1999 respectively. Then we evaluated each of the diagnosis tests according to the international standards. Results We searched 408 original articles in "Chinese Journal of Radiology" in which the diagnostic test articles were 12%, and 796 original articles in "Radiology" with the diagnostic test articles 23% from 1998 to 1999 respectively. In these diagnosis tests, by comparing the "Chinese journal of radiology" with the "Radiology", it was found that 19% applied blind comparison with Gold Standard, 28% calculated sensitivity, specificity and accuracy, 9% both calculated negative predictive value and positive predictive value and none calculated likelihood ratios in the former versus 64%, 57%, 33% and 26% and 3% respectivdy in the latter. Conclusions Compared with the international level, both the quality and the quantity of the diagnosis tests applied in the specialty of imaging scientific study in China are much lower and far from meeting the clinical requirement. Improving the methods of scientific study and carrying on more diagnosis tests with high qualities are of important significance in improving the diagnostic level of imaging.
目的 为避免选择和发表偏倚,系统评价者应采用多种查询技术,并尽力获得未发表的研究.本文试图探讨,英特网检索对鉴定未发表和正在进行的临床试验是否有用.研究设计 利用七个Cochrane系统评价的查询策略回顾性地在英特网上检索未纳入的随机对照试验.方法 检索策略 以普通检索式"研究方法学 NEAR干预措施NERA 条件"、用AltaVista在英特网上搜索.测量指标包括搜索时间、英特网搜索已发表研究的回溯率、精确度(已发表和未发表的随机临床试验链接的网页比例)、英特网检索到的未纳入的未发表和正在进行的研究数.结果 用21小时查询了429个网页,找到14个链接到未发表的、正在进行的或最近完成的试验,至少有9个与4篇系统评价相关.英特网检索已发表研究文献的回溯率在0～43.6%,其链接已发表和未发表研究的精确度在0～20.2%.结论 未发表尤其是正在进行的试验的信息可在英特网上找到.潜在的问题是如何评价未经同行评审的电子出版物的质量.急需更强的搜索工具.建议用"Open Trial Initiative"定义英特网发表试验的语法,以加强试验登记的共同操作性.因此,专门的搜索引擎可找到更多有关正在进行和已完成的临床试验信息.
Objective To investigate the preoperative design and application of the minimum foveolar translocation distance and angle of macular translocation. Methods The fundus fluorescein and indocyanine green an giographies were performed on 53 eyes of 53 patients with classic subfoveal choroidal neovascularization （SCNV）, including 42 with exudative age-related macular degeneration and 11 with high myopic macular degeneration. The actual area of macular SCNV and the minimum foveolar translocation distance and angle were analyzed. Results The actual area of SCNV was 0.39~18.00 mm2 with the mean of (3.08±3.22) mm2. The designed minimum superior translocation distance was 67~2 240μm with the mean of (845.72±425.23) μm；the minimum designed minimum inferior translocation distance was 53~2 430 μm with the mean of (912.17±547.77) μm. The minimum designed superior translocation angle was 1~32°with the mean of (13.23±6.6 8)°；the minimum designed inferior translocation angle was 1~35°with the mean of (14.06±8.46)°. The individual difference of the minimum designed superior and inferior translocation distance was more than 500 μm in 16 eyes （30.19 % ）, and the difference of translocation angle was more than 10°in 11（20.75%）. Conclusion Preoperative design of minimum translocation distance and angle of macular translocation may be helpful to choose the operation program. (Chin J Ocul Fundus Dis，2004，20：75-77)
ObjectiveTo analyze the consistency of diagnostic results using simple and comprehensive reading methods on stereoscopic color fundus photographs of diabetic retinopathy (DR) with diabetic macular edema (DME). Methods450 sets of 7-field stereoscopic color fundus photographs of DR DME were compared to standard fundus photographs of early treatment and DR study group. The pictures were read by two groups of reader with similar experience. Two strategies were used to make the judgments, including simple reading which based on the color fundus photographs only, and comprehensive reading which based on color fundus photographs, fundus fluorescein angiography (FFA) and optical coherence tomography (OCT). 15 parameters were scored, including micro-aneurysms (MA), intra-retinal hemorrhage (IRH), hard exudates (HE), cotton wood spot (CW), intra-retinal microvascular abnormalities (IRMA), neovascularization on optic disc (NVD), neovascularization elsewhere (NVE), optic fiber proliferation (FPD), fiber proliferation elsewhere (FPE), pre-retinal hemorrhage (PRH), vitreous hemorrhage (VH), retinal elevation (RE), retinal detachment of central macular (RDC), venous beading (VB), Venous leak (VL). The reliability was evaluated using weighted κ(κw) statistic values. According to Fleiss statistical theory, κw≥0.75, consistency is excellent; 0.60≤κw < 0.75, consistency is good; 0.40≤κw < 0.60, consistency is general; κw < 0.40, consistency is poor. ResultsThe κw values of these 15 parameters were 0.22-1.00, 0.28-1.00 for the simple reading and comprehensive reading respectively. For simple reading, the consistency was poor for 8 parameters (MA, NVD, NVE, FPE, PRH, IRMA, VB, VL), general for 3 parameters (CW, FPD, VH), good for 2 parameters (IRH, HE) and excellent for 2 parameters (RE, RDC). For comprehensive reading, the consistency was poor for 2 parameters (NVE, VB), general for 6 parameters (MA, IRH, CW, FPE, IRMA, VL), good for 2 parameters (NVD, HE), excellent for 5 parameters (FPE, PRH, VH, RE, RDC). ConclusionThe comprehensive reading has higher consistency to judge the abnormality parameters of the fundus photographs of DR with DME.